It makes sense why real estate groups and developers’ lobbying entities have long pushed – consistently and insidiously – the argument that New York City rent stabilization is all about affordability for the metro’s most cash-pressured tenants.
As a recent opinion letter to the Crain’s New York Business publication notes, that argument disingenuously promotes “the notion that rent regulation is a kind of welfare or housing-affordability program.”
Pushing that idea enables the pro-landlord crowd – large, powerful and well connected in NYC – to peg every problem with the system to allegations that it “is broken because deserving tenants [are] not precisely targeted.” And while they aren’t, the argument posits, undeserving renters are exploiting loopholes at landlords’ expense to garner unfair advantages.
A triad of long-time NYC legal veterans and pro-tenant advocates – including Himmelstein Gribben & Joseph LLP partner Sam Himmelstein – responds to the real estate industry’s arguments in the above-cited opinion piece.
And it illuminates them for what they are – fiction.
In truth, those writers note, rent regulation is vitally important “to neutralize market distortions.” Doing so better ensures a system of fair rents for dwellers residing in a select class of housing. The system has never sought to promote affordability per se.
The writers duly note the arrogant assumption of the realty industry that tenant groups are always thriving at their expense. Arguably, government development programs (e.g., parks, subways, water/waste) have benefited landlords, builders and management companies most of all.
And there is this disconnect: The housing industry persistently complains that its principals are going into debt subsidizing tenants, when data reveal that rising rental values are “beating inflation in multiples.”
The housing playing field is not even and fundamentally fair, and it never has been. Removing regulatory controls would not promote greater rationality and more equitable outcomes, as housing groups argue. Rather, it would most surely ensure a material destabilization of New York City’s diverse and vibrant neighborhoods.
If your tenant rights have been violated in New York, we’re here to help. Contact the experienced tenant rights lawyers at Himmelstein Gribben & Joseph LLP today to schedule a free consultation.
We proudly serve New York City, including the Bronx, Brooklyn, Manhattan, Queens, and Staten Island.
Himmelstein Gribben & Joseph LLP
15 Maiden Ln 17th Floor, New York, NY 10038
Phone: (212) 349-3000
Our firm is located near you. We have an office in New York
Find us with our GeoCoordinates: 40.709523,-74.009046,1563
Hire us and you don’t get just one attorney – you get a
team of professionals ready to help. Call us at
(212) 349-3000 or reach us online today to schedule an
appointment.
One hour consultation $400.00.
We don’t represent landlords and only handle cases in NYC.
Fields Marked With An “*” Are Required
"*" indicates required fields
Your Landlord Has A Lawyer.
You Need One, Too.
People often make the mistake of trying to manage a landlord-tenant dispute on their own. Without experienced legal counsel, however, it is easy to make the situation worse. We are skilled at negotiating with landlords, and fighting evictions in housing court and Supreme Court.
Himmelstein Gribben
& Joseph LLP
© 2026 Manhattan Tenant Rights & Representation Attorney. All rights reserved.
